Call us today: (914) 769-0417
  • You Only Have 10 Minutes...

    We know you hate long insurance forms and don’t have a lot of time! Just fill out our simple form and we'll back to you for the rest.

    If you want some insurance coverage for the Westchester region of New York state, try us out.

    Off we go...
  • Vrooooom! Car Insurance...

    We understand that car insurance is essential so make it as affordable as we can with valued carriers. Gives you peace of mind.

    Or a helping hand when you have an accident or some dolt reverses into your prized possession in the grocery store car park!

    Find out more...
  • Businesses Come in all Sizes...

    We cover contractors to plumbers, painters to electricians, retailers and restaurants, florists, small grocers, dentists, chiropractors, auto repair shops, and beauty salons.

    Are you in here? Not happy with your current provider or starting up. We were there once.

    Let's get going...
  • Life Insurance REALLY Matters

    Right? It can not only cover your family in case you pop your clogs but can act as a pretty nifty savings vehicle.

    Bet you didn't know that! We have partnered with a trusted and recognizable carrier to bring you the best plan ever. Well, it's pretty darned good!

    Save a life now...
  • An Englishman's Home is his Castle...

    Well, our English friend told us that so why wouldn't we believe him? Whether you are a condo owner, renter or home owner, you cannot do without coverage so let's make it as affordable as we can.

    Try us out...

Serving Hawthorne, NY, and Surrounding Communities

Let's face it. Getting an insurance quote can be a pain in the you-know-what. Well, we know that so we try and make it as painless as possible. Let us know the basics then we'll get right back in touch for the details.

We have been serving the insurance needs of our local communities since 1930. Over the years, businesses develop their own style, brand and niche, and we have adapted with them to make sure they are covered with the right insurance.

~ Bill, Tom, and the team

Need to get in touch quickly?

If you have questions about your existing insurance or are interested in using our services, please contact us below. We’ll get back to you as soon as possible.

Your name (required):

Your email (required):

How can we help?

Would you like to receive news from us and stay informed? YOU MUST CONFIRM IN THE FOLLOW-UP EMAIL.

Sure, add me to your email list

Just checking you are human…



Actual client testimonials from a recent independent study:

“We are completely satisfied when we deal with McCarthy Insurance. Everything is done in a timely manner.” ~ Client

“Been a loyal customer for over 30 years and plan on staying for at least 30 more.” ~ Client

“I am very pleased to do business with McCarthy Insurance. I am kept informed of any increase or changes in my policy and they go out of their way to find better alternative, and always get back to me promptly. They are very courteous and pleasant to do business with. A complete 180 degrees from my previous broker.” ~ Client

“I am very happy that I switched to McCarthy Insurance. The staff is very knowledgeable and can answer my questions quickly. I also appreciate a ‘live’ person picking up the phone on the first ring!” ~ Client

Latest News

Who Are We?

Established in 1930 by Dennis F. McCarthy, McCarthy Insurance is a firm of proven professionals and caring and conscientious people; the kind of people you can depend on. We mean that.

Find out why…

Our Carriers

Common question, easy answer.

See a our valued insurance carriers as well as links to their websites. From Progressive to Travelers, Chubb to Merchants Insurance, take a look then find the answers!


All work and no play makes for a dull life, so perhaps you’ve just bought a great new motorcycle, boat, ATV, jet ski, snowmobile or Gulfstream jet.

Okay, we’re kidding about the jet. Protect your toys today...

About Us

We are located in Hawthorne (in the Westchester region), just north of White Plains, just north of New York. You know, the Big Apple.

Do not hesitate to contact us should you have any questions…

Sign up for Email News

Would you like to receive news from us and stay informed? YOU MUST CONFIRM IN THE FOLLOW-UP EMAIL.

Contact Us

McCarthy Insurance
378 Elwood Avenue
Hawthorne, NY 10532
Phone: (914) 769-0417

McCarthy Insurance office